Benvenuti
Ristorante & Bar — Amsterdam, New York
Authentic Italian-American cuisine, warm atmosphere,
generous portions since the start
Our Story
Nestled along Route 30 in Amsterdam, Nicolino's has become one of the 518's most beloved spots for a proper Italian-American meal. Whether it's a weeknight dinner or a special celebration, we bring the warmth of a family kitchen and the craft of scratch cooking to every plate.
Our menu celebrates the classics — homemade gnocchi Bolognese, golden eggplant parmesan, penne alla vodka loaded with shrimp — alongside hand-cut steaks and daily fresh seafood. Everything is made to order, portioned generously, and served with the same bread basket that keeps regulars coming back.
Reserve up to 1 year in advance. Custom packages, full menu access, and private event coordination — we handle the details so you can enjoy the moment.
Private Events & Catering
Nicolino's is the perfect backdrop for life's most memorable moments. Our team handles every detail — from custom menu design to event coordination — so your guests can focus on celebrating.
All regular menu items are available, plus exclusive catering-only options crafted for large gatherings. Ask us about our party packages when you call.
What People Are Saying
"The portions were huge and our meals were freshly made and piping hot. Jocelyn was an excellent server — everything came out perfectly staggered. Excellent choice for Italian food!"
— Recent Guest
"The atmosphere was fantastic. The food was delicious and tasted fresh, made to order. The bartender was great and attentive. This is definitely a spot to check out."
— Rodger N.T.
"Their penne a la vodka with shrimp was fantastic — a good amount of shrimp and a beautiful blush sauce. The bread basket with roasted garlic olive oil is something else."
— Yelp Reviewer
"I have been coming here for years. The food is excellent and there is plenty of it. The service is friendly and eager to serve. One of the best Italian restaurants in the area."
— Regular Guest, 30+ Years
When To Find Us
* Hours may vary on holidays. Call ahead to confirm.
Find Us
We'd Love to See You
Call to reserve a table, ask about tonight's specials, or inquire about catering your next event. We're happy to help — and the bread basket is already warm.
Reserve Your Table (518) 842-4907or
Send Us a Message